I N 2003 AN investigation into Eric Poehlman, an expert on ageing and obesity, found that he had faked data. He was imprisoned for using made-up results to win grants. Journals duly withdrew his work. The Economist Today Hand-picked stories, in your inbox A daily email with the best of our journalism Sign up This should have ended his impact on academia. It didn't. One of his articles, on the composition of women's bodies, has been cited 400 times since it was retracted. Such wrongdoing is rare: around one in 2,500 studies is retracted. Yet papers that do get retracted often have long afterlives. Scholarship works like building blocks, with each paper citing myriad studies. This makes expunging the taint of a junk article impossible. Even though retracting a paper weakens all existing work that has referred to it, those studies remain on the books. A zombie article like Mr Poehlman's, which keeps getting cited even after it is withdrawn, sounds much worse. In fact it is the norm. To track such mishaps, we fed a list of 20,000 withdrawn papers in an archive amassed by Retraction Watch, a non-profit group, into Semantic Scholar, a database of academic references. Of… Read full this story
- The Default: Rebuttals Not Retractions (several updates)
- How to Avoid Shaming Yourself and Your Field in the Academic Online Open Access Publishing Jungle
- Wanted: 6,000 new journals to publish 150,000 papers
- Tech titan Nathan Myhrvold revisits NASA asteroid argument in peer-reviewed paper
- Game not over: Nintendo turns reports of its demise into Nintendo Mania with Switch console
- How We Got to Be So Self-Absorbed: The Long Story
- If you’re a Facebook user, you’re also a research subject
- How do elites manage to hijack voters’ ideas of themselves? – Sharun Mukand & Dani Rodrik
- Indian Journal of Medical Ethics Troubles Deepen as Editorial Team Responds to Criticism
- Adrian Piper’s Show at MoMA is the Largest Ever for a Living Artist. Why Hasn’t She Seen It?
Retracted academic papers linger long after their supposed demise have 323 words, post on www.economist.com at June 26, 2021. This is cached page on Vietnam Dance. If you want remove this page, please contact us.